KTEP - El Paso, Texas

Hopi Look To Tourism, Ranching For Income After Coal Power Plant Closure

Jan 14, 2020
Originally published on January 20, 2020 3:31 pm

For decades, coal has been at the center of Hopi life, literally. In the middle of each home is a coal-burning stove that keeps families warm through the winter.

"A lot of people relied on the coal to heat their homes and ceremonial chambers, the kivas," says Leigh Wayne Lomayestewa, who works in the tribe's cultural preservation office. "And now we're only relying on the cedar wood."

But he says cedar doesn't burn as long as coal.

"Usually at nighttime, you can put in about two or three times a night," Lomayestewa says.

When the West's largest coal-fired power plant shut down late last year in northern Arizona, it marked the end of an era. It took with it hundreds of jobs and $12 million in yearly royalties paid to the Hopi Tribe. That's 80% of the tribe's annual budget. Now, Hopi leaders are trying to figure out how to replace this economic lifeline.

Two years ago, the plant's operators, a group of utilities, voted to shut it down. Natural gas had become cheaper than complying with the coal plant's air quality regulations. Hopi Vice Chairman Clark Tenakhongva says that's left both Navajo and Hopi Tribes scrambling to find new sources of revenue.

"So with really nothing right now over the horizon with what revenues we have," Tenakhongva says, "what investments we have over the last 40 to 50 years at the level we're operating, we could survive another six to seven years on what we have."

That doesn't give them much time to come up with a new way of making money. Tenakhongva says the tribe has many options. It's just a matter of agreeing on one.

Wide range of alternatives

"We've got property in Winslow," Tenakhongva says. "We've got the I-40 corridor that has mass amounts of land that could be developed. The money's not going to come there the first two years but by 8 to 10 years we'll have something that we can say, 'yeah, this is the Hopi casino. Yeah, this is the Hopi ranches serving nothing but prime Hopi beef.'"

There's also tourism. Guide Meredith Qotswisiwma drives up the switchbacks to the historic Walpi Village. She says tourism has been a challenge because of the tribe's location. They're isolated, completely surrounded by the Navajo Nation.

"We're in a remote area so money-wise it's hard for us to go out and even advertise our tourism program," Qotswisiwma says. "So it's really hard."

The Hopi are working with the Navajo to build a road that would loop them into popular destinations like Monument Valley and Canyon de Chelly for tour companies coming from Las Vegas.

The tribe is even open to unusual ideas like the one pitched by engineer T.J. Agardy who came to a recent tribal council meeting. He's proposing technology used in Germany and Japan to harvest coalbed methane and turn it into natural gas.

"When we're done, that equipment stays here," Agardy told the tribal council. "You now have the ability to take and power yourselves up for the next 300 years."

He offered that long-term energy production solution and revenue stream as an alternative to the more short-term thinking of coal.

"If you look at what happened before," said Agardy, "you're left with an empty hole and a lot of empty promises."

The Hopi are cautious about any of these possibilities because they've been burned before by the federal government, other outside investors and even by other tribes.

Vice-Chairman Tenakhongva knows many people have left the reservation and many more will follow without better economic opportunities. But Tenakhongva says he's not going anywhere. He's got two years left of his term. And he plans to find a solution to the tribe's economic crisis before his time is up.

More than ever, Tenakhongva is trying to hold onto what he calls his Hopi optimism.

"The sun will come up tomorrow," Tenakhongva says. "We will continue to live but maybe not at the level of the comforts of what we have had."

Copyright 2020 KJZZ. To see more, visit KJZZ.

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

When the largest coal-fired power plant in the western U.S. shut down late last year, it marked the end of an era for the Hopi Tribe. The Navajo Generating Station once brought hundreds of jobs and millions of dollars in royalties to the Hopi Tribe. Now tribe leaders are trying to figure out how to replace it all. Laurel Morales of member station KJZZ reports.

LAUREL MORALES, BYLINE: For decades, coal has been at the center of Hopi life, literally. In the middle of each home is a coal-burning stove that keeps families warm through the winter.

LEIGH WAYNE LOMAYESTEWA: A lot of people relied on the coal to heat their homes and ceremonial chambers, the kivas. And now, you know, we're only relying on the cedarwood.

MORALES: Leigh Wayne Lomayestewa, who works in the tribe's cultural preservation office, says cedar doesn't burn as long as coal.

LOMAYESTEWA: Usually, at nighttime, you can put in about two or three times a night.

MORALES: In addition to heat, the tribe relied on the coal industry's royalty checks to cover 80% of its budget. Two years ago, the plant's operators, a group of utilities, voted to shut it down. Natural gas had become cheaper than complying with the coal plant's air quality regulations. Hopi Vice Chairman Clark Tenakhongva says that's left both Navajo and Hopi Tribes scrambling to find new sources of revenue.

CLARK TENAKHONGVA: So with really nothing right now over the horizon, with what revenues we have, what investments we have over the last 40, 50 years, at the level we're operating, we could survive another six to seven years on what we have.

MORALES: That doesn't give them much time to come up with a new way of making money. Tenakhongva says they have many options. It's just a matter of agreeing on one.

TENAKHONGVA: We've got property in Winslow. We've got the I-40 corridor that has mass amounts of land that could be developed.

MORALES: He understands this might take some time, but the Hopi could eventually say...

TENAKHONGVA: Yeah, this is a Hopi casino. Yeah, this is the Hopi ranches, serving nothing but prime Hopi beef.

MORALES: There's also tourism. Guide Meredith Qotswisiwma drives up the switchbacks to the historic Walpi Village. She says tourism has been a challenge because of the tribe's location. They're isolated, completely surrounded by the Navajo Nation.

MEREDITH QOTSWISIWMA: We're in a remote area, so money-wise, it's hard for us to go out and even advertise our tourism program. So it's really hard.

MORALES: The Hopi here working with the Navajo to build a road that would loop them into popular destinations, like Monument Valley and Canyon de Chelly for tour companies coming from Las Vegas. The tribe is even open to unusual ideas, like the one pitched by engineer T.J. Agardy, who came to a recent tribal council meeting. Agardy is proposing technology used in Germany and Japan to harvest coalbed methane and turn it into natural gas.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

TJ AGARDY: When we're done, that equipment stays here. You now have the ability to take and power yourselves up for the next 300 years. If you look at what happened before, you're left with an empty hole and a lot of empty promises.

MORALES: The Hopi are cautious about any of these possibilities because they've been burned before by the federal government, other outside investors and even by other tribes. But more than ever, Vice Chairman Tenakhongva says he's trying to hold on to what he calls his Hopi optimism.

TENAKHONGVA: The sun will come up tomorrow. We will continue to live but maybe not at the level of the comforts of what we have had.

MORALES: He knows many people have left the reservation, and many more will follow. But Tenakhongva says he's not going anywhere. He's got two years left of his term, and he plans to find a solution before his time is up.

For NPR News, I'm Laurel Morales in Flagstaff. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.