Your Source for NPR News & Music
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Alleged recordings between Walmart mass shooting victim's family and Vinton Municipal Judge filed in district court

A family photo of Rosa Maria Valdez Garcia and Alexander Gerhard Hoffman
Courtesy photo
A family photo of Rosa Maria Valdez Garcia and Alexander Gerhard Hoffman

EL PASO, Texas (KTEP) - Audio and videos recorded by the relatives of a victim in the Walmart mass shooting filed in district court in El Paso include detailed conversations in which a man allegedly threatened them.

Attorney Justin Underwood filed the audio and video on Friday. He was appointed to represent the family of Alexander Gerhard Hoffman, who was killed in the mass shooting.

The family says the voice on the recordings is Roger Rodriguez, a municipal judge in Vinton who told the Hoffmans he worked for the El Paso’s District Attorney’s office.

In one section of audio, Thomas Hoffman, Alexander’s son, is allegedly heard talking to Rodriguez about a day they were at a store in Juárez called Sanborns.

“That as a friend, you’re good and as an enemy, even better. I mean, I take that as you trying to threaten her,” Thomas Hoffman says.

“I did not threaten your mother,” Rodriguez replies.

Audio from Hoffman family (Sanborn)
“That as a friend, you’re good and as an enemy, even better. I mean, I take that as you trying to threaten her,” Thomas Hoffman says.<br/><br/>“I did not threaten your mother,” Rodriguez replies.

The audio also details Rodriguez’s alleged role in a mysterious email sent to media that falsely claimed District Court Judge Sam Medrano’s court was under investigation.

It was sent from an email address belonging to Hoffmans widow Rosa Maria Valdez Garcia and was signed by their son Alexander. On the recording, Rodriguez blames Alexander Hoffmans daughter, Elise Hoffman-Taus, for questioning whether her relatives really wrote the email.

“Everything would have turned out alright, but no one told us about your sister,” according to the translated transcript of a conversation between Rodriguez and Thomas Hoffman.

Audio from Hoffman family ("We feel used")
We don't want our family's name to be used to make a circus, and we feel used, okay.

Underwood was appointed to represent the family in the case by District Court Judge Sam Medrano on August 17th.

On one recording the man identified as Rodriguez in the court filing encourages Hoffman to avoid contact with the District Attorney’s office.

On Thursday, Underwood filed allegations against Rodriguez and District Attorney Yvonne Rosales, accusing them of victimizing the Hoffman family. Underwood, a private attorney, stated he made contact with the family of Alexander Hoffman, after prosecutors said they could not reach them.

District Attorney Rosales denied Rodriguez works for her office during a hearing last week.

This story will be updated.

Related Stories